Argentum Solutions, Inc.

    Sterling guidance on corrosion and materials degradation


 

Potential-pH Diagrams
THERMEXPERT - Potential-pH diagram generator

Intelligent Tools

POLEXPERT - Polarization Scan Artificial Neural Network Expert System

SEQEXPERT - Sequential Immersion Test Artificial Neural Network Expert System

CYLEXPERT - Rotating Cylinder Electrode Intelligent Rotation Rate Calculator

Corrosion Calculator

Corrosion Rate Calculator

Corrosion Economics Estimator

FINCALCULATOR - Corrosion Economic Calculator


TUTORIAL ON THERMEXPERTTM
Potential-pH (Pourbaix or EMF-pH) Diagram Generator

David C. Silverman


Table of Contents

Overview of Tutorial
Using THERMEXPERT - a step-by-step procedure
Background on the Potential/pH (Pourbaix) Diagram
Generation of a diagram - Iron in water
        Case Study-Titanium/chloride under acidic conditions
Case Study-Complexing Agents-Iron/iminodiacetic acid
THERMEXPERT-generating web-based potential-pH diagrams

Generation of a diagram - Iron in water

An internally consistent thermodynamic data base has to be available before the potential-pH diagram can be calculated and applied to practical corrosion prediction. One possible procedure for ensuring consistency might be summarized in this figure . This approach was applied to calculation of the potential-pH diagram for iron at 25C. The details for the approach are presented in D. C. Silverman, "Presence of Solid Fe(OH)2 in EMF-pH Diagram for Iron", Corrosion, Vol. 38, p. 453 (1982) 1    (172k). In that paper Fe+2 and Fe+3 were used directly from published thermodynamic data for those ions. Required thermodynamic values for other ions were estimated by combining the tabulated value for the non-hydrolyzed iron species and the equilibrium constant between it and the next hydrolyzed species in the sequence (e.g. between Fe+2 and FeOH+). Thermodynamic properties of each of the subsequent hydrolyzed species of the same valence were calculated using the next higher hydrolysis reaction. Hydrolysis constants are available in the literature. Solids and oxides were used as tabulated in the literature. The following table reproduces the free energy data as presented in the above publication.

Compound Free Energy @298K
joule/mole
Fe 0
Fe3O4 -1.02x106
Fe2O3 -7.42x105
FeOOH -4.90x105
Fe(OH)2-solid -4.93x105
Fe(OH)3-solid -7.14x105
Fe+2 -9.22x104
FeOH+ -2.75x105
Fe(OH)2-aqueous -4.49x105
Fe(OH)3- -6.21x105
Fe+3 -1.78x104
FeOH+2 -2.42x105
Fe(OH)2+ -4.59x105
Fe(OH)3-aqueous -6.61x105
Fe(OH)4- -8.43x105
Fe2(OH)2+4 -4.94x105
Fe3(OH)4+5 -9.69x105
FeO4-2??
(may not exist)
-4.67x105


Data such as those shown in the above table were run through THERMEXPERT to create the "Metal State Diagram" and "Solution State Diagram" for iron. The temperature was 25oC and the activities of the ions were 10-6. As discussed in the section entitled Background on the Potential/pH (Pourbaix) Diagram. the "Metal State Diagram" shows the expected lowest free energy state of the solid metal, in this case iron. It can be as metal (e.g. Fe), oxidized metal (e.g. Fe2O3), or dissolved ion (e.g. Fe+2). The "Solution State Diagram" shows the expected lowest free energy state for the dissolved species associated with the compound in the "Metal State Diagram". If at a certain pH and potential the lowest free energy state in the "Metal State Diagram" is an ion, that same ion would appear at that same pH and potential in the "Solution State Diagram".

In addition, these diagrams have been generated after removing from consideration related species that are not at lowest free energy but which might appear on an initially calculated diagram because their formation from each other does not involve hydrogen ion or valence change. Such species are related only by addition or removal of water. The pH and potential are not variables in these reactions. In this case, examples are reactions among Fe2O3, FeOOH, Fe(OH) 3, and the dissolved Fe(OH)3(aq). These four compounds are related only through a reaction with water. All might initially appear on the same calculated diagram in some pH and potential region since they are related only through reaction with water and neither hydrogen ion or electron transfer (change in valence state) are not involved. In this case, the compound Fe2O3 was chosen over FeOOH even though the latter might have a slightly lower free energy of formation among reactions that include water and those other compounds. One might substitute one of the other compounds for consideration if the system being modeled requires it. These points are also discussed in the section Using THERMEXPERT - a step-by-step procedure.

The potential-pH diagram which is most familiar to people is the overlay of these two diagrams. Such an overlay is shown in this figure . The darker borders and print signify the lowest free energy state of the solid iron, the "Metal State Diagram". The lighter borders and print signify the lowest free energy state of the dissolved species that would be associated with the species in the "Metal State Diagram". These ions arise from the "Solution State Diagram". The diagrams predict the same state where the only species is the same dissolved species on both diagrams at the same position. For example, Fe+2 and Fe+3 in both diagrams where they are the most thermodynamically stable species at the same potential and pH in both diagrams. The two diagrams are not in equilibrium with each other so the overlays are not in equilibrium with each other. Also, note that both FeOOH and Fe2O3 have been included.

As discussed in the publication D. C. Silverman, "Presence of Solid Fe(OH)2 in EMF-pH Diagram for Iron", Corrosion, Vol. 38, p. 453 (1982) 1    (172k), this combined diagram differs from that originally published in (M. Pourbaix, Atlas of Electrochemical Equilibria in Aqueous Solutions, NACE International, Houston, TX, 1974). The most important differences are a region of stability of solid Fe(OH)2 that lies between the iron and magnetite regions of stability and a region of stability for Fe(OH)4- at high pH and somewhat elevated potentials. Solid Fe(OH)2 would be expected to impart only imperfect corrosion resistance. Indeed, as shown in that older reference, corrosion of iron has been observed in this pH and potential region. Dissolved Fe(OH)4- is a corrosion product suggesting that dissolved metal is the most stable state in this high pH region. Corrosion in this pH region and somewhat elevated potential region has been observed in strongly caustic processes. The diagram also shows the complete spectrum of hydrolysis products.



Previous Page: Background on the Potential/pH (Pourbaix) Diagram

Next Page: Case Study-Titanium/chloride under acidic conditions

Return to Table of Contents

Enter THERMEXPERT



1 © NACE International publication and year shown in citation above. All rights reserved. Displayed with permission from NACE International, Houston, TX (http://www.nace.org). Published in Corrosion, in the month and year shown in the citation above.






David C. Silverman, Ph.D. - Primary Consultant
E-Mail:     dcsilverman@argentumsolutions.com
Phone:     314-576-3586
Fax:         314-754-9825
Address:   The Argentum House
                14314 Strawbridge Ct.
                Chesterfield, MO 63017